GOOD OLD MUSIC: SO NICE, THEY FLIPPED IT TWICE


The Parliaments: Good Old Music
From 7″ (Revilot, 1968)

The Magic Tones: Good Old Music
From 7″ (Westbound, 1969)

Funkadelic: Good Old Music
From S/T (Westbound, 1970

I was so enamored with the Magic Tones 7″ I wrote about the other month that I went to go look for other material by this Detroit band and then came upon their version of Funkadelic’s “Good Ole Music.” George Clinton must have straight up loved this song since he basically recorded it three different times. The first came on the pre-P-Funk Parliaments and it’s very interesting to hear how the song sounded in its original form, especially since all the foundational elements are right there – the drum break, the bassline, the guitar riff. By the time the song gets to Funkadelic, Clinton gives it a remarkable makeover. The tempo feels slower and all those key components I just named are made bolder and, in my opinion, better. The drum break, of course, is now legendary but what absolutely crushes in this new recording are those guitars. What was once fuzzed out is now practically heavy metal. Dr. Dre was obviously a big fan of all of this since he used different parts of the song for two of my favorite pre-Chronic productions, Above the Law’s “Another Execution” and The D.O.C.’s “The D.O.C. and the Doctor” (side note: I cannot hear that D.O.C. song without always thinking, “what could have been.” It’s such a monster tune; easily one of the best things to come out of L.A. in the early ’90s).

But wait…I assumed the Magic Tones version was basically the Funkadelic instrumental track with new vocals but given that the Magic Tones single supposedly came out in 1969 and the self-titled Funkadelic LP didn’t drop until 1970, could it be that Clinton used the Magic Tones release as a test run for what would eventually be Funkadelic’s?

Comments

comment(s)

7 comments to GOOD OLD MUSIC: SO NICE, THEY FLIPPED IT TWICE

  • Larry Grogan

    It wouldn’t surprise me if he did the Magictones first, considering the histories of ‘I’ll Bet You’ and ‘Look at What I Almost Missed’ (there are probably others where the Parliaments or Funkadelic versions came second that I’m missing)

  • D.Ma

    love it! the magic tone’s version slays, thanks my dude!

  • Pierre C

    I picked up a VG-/+ copy of the Magic Tones version a couple of years back. I’m not a big fan of hiss and crackle, but the tune, break and all, just ploughs through the wear and tear. A favourite.

  • A. Dubs

    Man…very nice. However, I had to follow your aside to my favorite N.W.A. solo artist (Ice Cube’s Amerikkka’s Most would’ve been first had he completed in house). I agree–what could have been?!?!

  • Andreas

    Apparently (according to Wikipedia via some hiphop site) D.O.C. has had vocal chord surgery and has an album on the way… this is probably super outdated “news”, but just saying… he might still blow up. You never know.

    In any case, love the site (big fan) and keep up the good work!

  • Charlene

    Huge fan—–L O V E the site!!!! 🙂

  • Alex

    Hi there, I enjoyed reading your thoughts on the early P-Funk. Have you checked out P-Theory?

    We are just about to release our third album Redemption which features Billy Bass (founding member of the original Funkadelic) on 5 of the 12 tracks. Our frontman is Kevin Goins (Glenn’s brother) so if you like your Funkadelic vibes I’m sure you’ll find something interesting there.

    If you sign up as a member to the website you can download a preview of the full album for free.

    http://p-theory.com

Leave a Reply

 

 

 

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>