BLACK MOON VS. BLACK MOON VS. BLACK MOON


Black Moon: I Gotcha Opin
From Enta Da Stage(Nervous, 1993)

I Got Cha Opin remix
Buck ‘Em Down remix
Both from respective 12″s (Nervous/Wreck, 1994)

This is a resurrection from a 2004 post and was mostly inspired by re-listening to Funkmaster Flex’s now famous July 4, 2007 “I’m in the 90s!” set on Hot 97 where he just goes IN on the LP version of “I Got Cha Opin.”

The original question I posed was this: this may be one of the most difficult debates ever to exist in hip-hop. More than Nas vs. Jay-Z. More than Bad Boy vs. Death Row. More than J.J. Fad vs. Salt N’ Pepa.

Which Black Moon remix is better, “I Got Cha Opin” or “Buck ‘Em Down”?

How can you choose between Barry White’s “Playing Your Game” and Donald Byrd’s “Wind Parade,” both beautifully reworked by the Beatminerz? Seriously ya’ll, this is like Bush/Gore ’00 all over again, it just too close to call and will have to be taken to the Supreme Court of Public Opinion.

But wait; in the 2012 revisit, we also have to ask…what’s better?

The LP version of “I Got Cha Opin” or the remix version? The former is pure black-out-the-city awesomeness but the latter was ethereal.

My personal opinion, after the jump…If I had to pick a best out of these three…I’d probably still go with the “Buck ‘Em Down” remix. It’s so well-crafted and such a clear step up for Da Beatminerz coming off the album. You can literally hear them coming into their own as the production crew was about to enter their most fertile era. But in terms of the rawest track? The original “I Got Cha Opin,” no question. In my fantasy movie score, this song would be used to open a film in the baddest way possible.

Comments

comment(s)

3 comments to BLACK MOON VS. BLACK MOON VS. BLACK MOON

  • Shells

    I remember hearing the remix to ‘I Got Cha Opin’ FIRST. I wasn’t up on Black Moon at that time, but then heard the album and was like ‘how come nobody’s talking about this version of the song?’

  • LOOT73

    in answer to the 2012 question…’I to cha opin’ rmx wins for sure but really they’re practically 2 different tracks…different rap etc.
    As for the best one, I’d def say ‘buck ’em down’ rmx, just a little way above ‘i got cha opin’ rmx tho. but they’re both classics and sampled from classic originals so its a tough call.

  • prince kc

    To remember east coast hip hop in 93′ & 94, you would have to remember that everything Black Moon released in terms of singles was bananas, compared favorably and was on par with anything being released at that time period(Wu tang/Onyx,etc),they had a HUGE following.

    I would say that both remixes were a little more advanced than the album versions.

    During the year or so that elapsed between the release of Enta Da Stage and the remixes in question, Buckshot’s rhyme style evolved to a point that his flow was more relaxed, effortless and sophisticated than when album first dropped . To this day, I still enjoy “I gotcha open” remix!

    The production on both the lp and singles/remixes were always outstanding, but to compare the verses/delivery on both I Gotcha Open and Buck Em Down, I think the remixes are superior.

Leave a Reply

 

 

 

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>